blanchard suggested
macro needed to disagregate management by building ---in ones mind-- many policy instruments
to manage a complex of many many interacting subsystems each requiring co ordinated sectoral intervention
paine translation
GOSPLAN II
Monday, March 14, 2011
peckerhead institute conference sum up
..
stig mumble bumbles with the usual gems
sum up in paine think
sometime in the dark 70's
we had a shift in cognative capture
after 30 years or more of chicago school capture
of mass taught and assumed micro
those sterile notions were used to capture
macro by the fire sector interests
ie destroy the keynesian reformation
yup
by re founding macro on utterly wonderland chamber of commerce micro
and this just when guys like stig akerloff and spence
were in the process of liberating cutting edge micro
from years of academic stagnation
-- the samuelson-arrow era ---
irony hey???
i love stigs line
we founded macro on the wrong micro
sum up in paine think
sometime in the dark 70's
we had a shift in cognative capture
after 30 years or more of chicago school capture
of mass taught and assumed micro
those sterile notions were used to capture
macro by the fire sector interests
ie destroy the keynesian reformation
yup
by re founding macro on utterly wonderland chamber of commerce micro
and this just when guys like stig akerloff and spence
were in the process of liberating cutting edge micro
from years of academic stagnation
-- the samuelson-arrow era ---
irony hey???
i love stigs line
we founded macro on the wrong micro
Saturday, March 12, 2011
putting the last two posts together
note the requirements of development in dani
competitive exchange rate
protect traditional sectors
the study chinn sites
"while aggregate output is not strongly affected, export growth falls significantly after appreciation shocks. Import growth remains by and large unchanged resulting in the observed deterioration in external balances."
and
" As aggregate economic growth is much less affected, our results point to a positive domestic demand response following appreciation episodes. "
is appreciation
in that context
a zap to development ???
does the short run violate
dani's competitive currenct proviso
or is the zap to exports a re shift away from low employment high productivity sectors
toward low productivity high employment sectors
apparently not to growth
or to export competing domestic industry
no import rate flab-alanche
only export rate shrink
not on top of this yet
competitive exchange rate
protect traditional sectors
the study chinn sites
"while aggregate output is not strongly affected, export growth falls significantly after appreciation shocks. Import growth remains by and large unchanged resulting in the observed deterioration in external balances."
and
" As aggregate economic growth is much less affected, our results point to a positive domestic demand response following appreciation episodes. "
is appreciation
in that context
a zap to development ???
does the short run violate
dani's competitive currenct proviso
or is the zap to exports a re shift away from low employment high productivity sectors
toward low productivity high employment sectors
apparently not to growth
or to export competing domestic industry
no import rate flab-alanche
only export rate shrink
not on top of this yet
dani and the bi forcation of development
"...countries with a strong comparative advantage in natural resources are particularly prone to fall into the trap of growth-reducing structural change. For these countries, globalization is a mixed blessing. The natural-resource industries that globalization promotes have limited capacity to absorb employment out of traditional sectors. Globalization therefore entrenches dualism, rather than helping to overcome it.
Appropriate policies can help. One lesson is to avoid premature collapse of import-competing industries that employ substantial numbers of people before sufficient employment opportunities have emerged in more productive industries. Asian countries, for instance, have typically liberalized at the margin (through export subsidies or special economic zones), spurring new export industries without pulling the rug from under the rest.
Second, the exchange rate is vitally important. Competitive currencies promote and protect modern tradable industries that employ a substantial share of the labor force. We found in our research that countries with competitive currencies were much more likely to experience growth-enhancing structural change.
Finally, flexible labor-market policies seem to be important, too. Legal requirements that significantly increase the costs of hiring and firing labor discourage employment creation in new industries.
Structural change does not automatically accelerate economic development. It needs a nudge in the appropriate direction, especially when a country has a strong comparative advantage in natural resources. Globalization does not alter this underlying reality. But it does increase the costs of getting the policies wrong, just as it increases the benefits of getting them right."
Appropriate policies can help. One lesson is to avoid premature collapse of import-competing industries that employ substantial numbers of people before sufficient employment opportunities have emerged in more productive industries. Asian countries, for instance, have typically liberalized at the margin (through export subsidies or special economic zones), spurring new export industries without pulling the rug from under the rest.
Second, the exchange rate is vitally important. Competitive currencies promote and protect modern tradable industries that employ a substantial share of the labor force. We found in our research that countries with competitive currencies were much more likely to experience growth-enhancing structural change.
Finally, flexible labor-market policies seem to be important, too. Legal requirements that significantly increase the costs of hiring and firing labor discourage employment creation in new industries.
Structural change does not automatically accelerate economic development. It needs a nudge in the appropriate direction, especially when a country has a strong comparative advantage in natural resources. Globalization does not alter this underlying reality. But it does increase the costs of getting the policies wrong, just as it increases the benefits of getting them right."
appreciating appreciation
" The study shows that currency appreciations can help to a certain extent in reducing global imbalances, and that it can go along with a shift from a mainly export-based model of growth towards a model with internal sources of growth. The cost in terms of growth would be very limited in the case of developed countries, but somewhat larger for developing countries.
The general results are illustrated by the impulse response functions:
Figure 1 from Kappler et al. (2011).
The effects are more pronounced when restricted to an emerging market/less developed country sample.
Figure 3 from Kappler et al. (2011).
From the conclusion:
Eichengreen and Rose find a detectable growth decrease, but hardly a collapse --, using a different approach to identifying appreciation episodes. Taken together, research seems to suggest that a substantial growth slowdown in the wake of a large currency appreciation is unlikely."
Figure 1 from Kappler et al. (2011).
The effects are more pronounced when restricted to an emerging market/less developed country sample.
Figure 3 from Kappler et al. (2011).
From the conclusion:
Using data for 128 countries between 1960 and 2008, we have found 25 episodes of large sustained exchange rate revaluations, which we define as both nominal and real effective exchange rate appreciations of 10% (and more) within a two year window (or less). Studying the institutional context of each individual episode in detail, we identified 14 cases of appreciation shocks that occurred not as a result of discretionary policy action, but were passively linked to the appreciation of the anchor currency in the context of an exchange rate peg. We argue that these cases represent instances of exogenous appreciation shocks that we can use to estimate the macroeconomic impact of large appreciations and assess the robustness of estimates based on a wider definition of appreciation and revaluation events. Using a dummy-augmented autoregressive panel model we could indeed show that such large appreciations episodes have strong macroeconomic effects. Most importantly, we established four key stylised facts that can prove useful in the ongoing debate about the role of exchange rate adjustment for global rebalancing.It is interesting to consider these results in the context of other studies. In particular, Eichengreen and Rose (2010) conducted an study of "...what happens to economies when they exit exchange rate pegs that are resisting appreciation. Data from 27 cases suggest that growth slows but only modestly, and there is no evidence of economic and financial damage as a result -- certainly nothing like the fears that China's next decade could look like Japan's lost decade." [pdf].
First, the current account balance typically falls strongly in response to large exchange rate revaluations. Three years after the revaluation, the current account balance deteriorates by about 3 pp. relative to GDP. This is due to a reduction in aggregate savings without a concomitant fall in investment. The effect on the current account balance is statistically significant and robust to variation in the country sample and the definition of appreciation events.
Second, the effects on output seem limited. Our point estimates suggest a negative effect of output growth, albeit of relatively small magnitude: on average, the aggregate level effect on output amounts to about 1% after six years. The confidence intervals are also considerably wider than for the current account. The output effects are statistically not significant.
Third, while aggregate output is not strongly affected, export growth falls significantly after appreciation shocks. Import growth remains by and large unchanged resulting in the observed deterioration in external balances. As aggregate economic growth is much less affected, our results point to a positive domestic demand response following appreciation episodes.
Fourth, these effects seem to be more pronounced in developing countries. The sensitivity of the current account balance to revaluation shocks is higher. The effect reaches almost 4 percentage points of GDP after three years and is statistically significant. But also the potentially negative effects on output are larger. Our point estimates indicate a loss in output of 2% over ten years. But confidence intervals remain wide, so that these results miss statistically significant levels. Why these effects are stronger in developing countries will be an important question that we aim to address in future research.
In sum, the historical record of large exchange rate revaluations that we have studied in this paper lends some support to the idea that large exchange rate appreciations and revaluations have an impact on the current account as they lead to marked changes of savings and investment within countries. Appreciation shocks impact external balances, but this effect potentially comes at the cost of a reduction of dynamism in exports. While the domestic economy seems to pick up some of the external slack, leaving overall growth relatively unaffected, the prospect of sharp decelerations in export growth will remain a concern for policy-makers and bears watching especially in the context of developing countries.
Eichengreen and Rose find a detectable growth decrease, but hardly a collapse --, using a different approach to identifying appreciation episodes. Taken together, research seems to suggest that a substantial growth slowdown in the wake of a large currency appreciation is unlikely."
Posted by Menzie Chinn at March 10, 2011 08:05 AM
mark up (mu) optimum with mark up warrent markets
where the change in mu over the change in units sold
equals
the change in warrent price over the change in units sold
not formal similarity to both credit ration and efficency wage model
equals
the change in warrent price over the change in units sold
not formal similarity to both credit ration and efficency wage model
nairu follies episode 10k plus 13 ....err ...u*
" apply the canonical Diamond-Mortensen-Pissarides model ... to the aggregate data on unemployment and vacancies.... the model and data do not provide a definitive measure of u*. Unemployment insurance benefits have increased since December 2007. Firms expect higher taxes and higher input prices. It is possible that these changes in labor market conditions may have been sufficiently large to generate a big increase in u* in the past three years. "
-num num lakota-
-num num lakota-
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
inflation effects of credit on product prices and one policy
the inter bank interest rate
in fact this amounted to only wage rate control
ie wage inflation was THE inflation
not the n inflations ie price level changes
in paper assets
land
commodities
and yes industrial products and services etc
blanchard in his chat
essentially grasps the depth and detail of any real control management of the credit system
many targets many instruments
something very real but questionable given FIRE sector interests
the FIRE brigade struck a tacit deal with the rest of the corporate community
we'll control your wages and provide the financial bridges to the entire planet
if you let us run amok
hence
the cyclops theory and
bubble up practice
keep
wage level change as target
and the bank's own inter-rate as steerage
ie
de facto laissez allez to the entire FIRE sector