Sunday, March 27, 2011

pk and me with others

pk's narrative is not wonky its honky tonky
its a piece of fast talk bs
--hey i agree with pk there's a price level "issue" here
that is trumped by a liquidity trap
remove the liquidity trap
and like opening pandora's box ...

at any rate here it is...
set up phase :

"suppose that we eventually go back to a situation in which interest rates are positive, so that monetary base and T-bills are once again imperfect substitutes;"
under specified what else is up here pk ??
what has pulled interest rates up into the positive regions ??
return of corporate spending
for what new us production capacity ??
how about
haywire increases in lending to households ??
for what house lot bubble ups ??
are we facing up to our trade deficit ???
or has it bulged out grotesquely

"also, we’re close enough to full employment that rapid economic expansion will once again lead to inflation."
ya just toss that in
but what are the mechanics of this bubala ??
are you really relying on this hand wave here ??
---------
attempt to use "numbers" to add precision

"The last time we were in that situation, the monetary base was around $800 billion."
------------------
now comes the clinker
despite full employment and real rates of interest
"Suppose.. we ... find ourselves back in that situation .." ie real rates nairu employment levels
wait for it
"with the government still running deficits of more than $1 trillion a year, say around $100 billion a month. "
make me see this in complete numbers paul
we've doubled back here
why are we running these big deficits
particularly if we've restored NAIRU levels
of employment ???
again trade gap ???
why is that not being addressed directly ???
yes you gotta close the trade gap for sure
then the magic moment
".. for whatever reason, we’re suddenly faced with a strike of bond buyers — nobody is willing to buy U.S. debt except at exorbitant rates."
what has created this moment ???
you gotta make it possible if not plausible
give us a scenario

"...for whatever reason..."
don't cut it here
if its a sky hook
if ou can't anchor this flight/panic
on a context that coheres ...
this really really needs
a historical analogy

-------------------------------
okay so far so stinky but
at any rate i swallow that for sake of argument
So then what?

"The Fed could directly finance the government by buying debt, or it could launder the process by having banks buy debt and then sell that debt via open-market operations; either way, the government would in effect be financing itself through creation of base money."
ya ya ya
so the trick is set
and sprong
our leg is caught in the teeth of it
" the first month’s financing would increase the monetary base by around 12 percent. And in my hypothesized normal environment, you’d expect the overall price level to rise (with some lag, but that’s not crucial) roughly in proportion to the increase in monetary base. And rising prices would, to a first approximation, raise the deficit in proportion."
but putting aside the melodramatics
what does this seem to suggest
dynamically that we could model ??
its comp stat talk
almost quantity theory of money
talk
and despite that
pk's pretending to play dynamics here
yet another big hand wave
the rest is artificial catastrophe
"So we’re talking about a monetary base that rises 12 percent a month, or about 400 percent a year."
oddly not satisfied with that
pk adds gas to the flames
"Does this mean 400 percent inflation? No, it means more — because people would find ways to avoid holding green pieces of paper, raising prices still further. "
the point:
show me
why macro policy is "...still running deficits of more than $1 trillion a year" ???

------------------..
what i DO agree with is this
we will need a mechanism to control price level movements

 if we want to use macro policy to reach
hyper employment without a price blow out
and of course restore balanced trade
that hole creates a structural demand for big fiscal deficits

------------------------------
"We want to control price level movements because they create inefficiencies"
yes
that is the usual point
but robust inflation might well improve
the dynamic efficiency of a market system no ??
to talk of control here may not mean reduce
but more centrally
a desire to manage inflation
i use the analogy to fire
now inflation in its wage push form
is like a wild fire
we try to put it out before it gets rolling
i think we oughta design and implement a social mechanism to control inflation
master it make it our tool
hence my endless and apparently solitary
flogging of a mark up or value added
cap and trade system
at least for our big outfits with obvious
bruce wilderesque "market power"
or for a rampant price rising sector
like health care
or duldrumous price contracting sector
like commodity production
---we kinda have these already but no where near as stream lined and self emerging as a mark up market could produce
produced by many small powerless producers

----------------------------------------.
" tie price levels to unemployment through a job guarantee at a fixed price
No more inflation, no more unemployment."
creating uncle's job gulag
is widely supported on the left
and it ought to be squashed
in my considered opinion
---we oughta get into that here somewhere btw---
but the job gulag
only puts a floor on market wages right ??
how does it put a ceiling on em ??
by opening the gulags gates ??
they're always open eh ??
by intentionally letting the gulag "real wage " shrink to dastardly non livable levels
mark my words
the dynamics of any job gulag would parallel the welfare system circa 65-95
ie slow misery inducing strangulation by agent demagogues
of the corporate plutocrats

---------------------------

running deficits for ever
is not the issue here is it ??
the issue is unhinging the bond markets
by expectations of such things as weimar
hyper inflation
and/or devaluation with its import price tsunami
lerner marshall day II
i note hyper inflations are the result of a tax system brake down combined with a BOP crisis
ie
its an open system problem
above pk
never addresses this "reality"
-------------------------------
"unemployment is the most egregious inefficiency."
amen

"Look at any chart of wealth distribution and you can easily see which class figured it out first"
not so sure
after all the gold system at full flood around the victorian era
certainly skewed wealth much as reagan dynamics skewed wealth
but i agree you can't run a real deindustrialization like we've seen here post nixon wimdow slam
quite so well
with a gold dollar link
like keynes-white designed at bretton woods
chronic trade deficits work better backed by a limitless unchecked dollar mine
-------------------
min
you give the vulgar street talk version of mmt
too much credit
pk albeit sloppy about the execution
is correct to throw up this caution sign
i think he was stung by dean baker

http://www.cepr.net/index.php/blogs/beat-the-press/krugman-is-wrong-the-united-states-could-not-end-up-like-greece?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+beat_the_press+%28Beat+the+Press%29
and side steps dean to wack a mole of another ilk
a particularly dumb mole that thinks
final answers grow on money trees
money trees that are endlessly and costlessly
currency baring
it however suggests something is eating at pk
he rarely shores up a position
no one has fired at
but maybe he was here merely guiding
the flock of independent thinking innocents
away from that particular cliff edge

-------------------------------
"I do think that there are real differences between Krugman's views and MMT.."

all the differences are worth excavating eh ??
but i think the nub is pk's tax talk
i submit pk 's line partly alibis
the austerians when he suggests
"we need new taxes "
his implication:
there is such a thing
as a finite fiscal borrowing space
but he has never suggested a rule for it
he prolly has in his head something like
a federal debt outstanding
( ie not in some pair of gubmint hands
or the fed's )
at 200% of gdp
once he pins that down
then extended high deficit regimes
like the present one
become problematic immediately
since the very form of the argument
allows say
a simple johnson or ken roguenutz
to set the bar at 100% of gdp
and cry wolf ......right now !!!
the trap he falls into by this debt burden ceiling
is of course he ends up calling for
a higher total tax yield
this gets opposed by the hoi polloi
now in year 30
of the take home median wage's rollicking ... snail rate of growth
whereas those un afraid of any debt limit
can suggest the system needs only to shift
a large measure of the existing
"full employment " extraction rate
( ~20% of gdp)
off theshoulders of the payroll class
and onto those of our upper wealth and passive income bracketeers
both new brackets and deeper cutting brackets

-------------------------
"they point out that historical cases of hyperinflation have always had some economic dislocation ...."
exactly so
pk needs to build a possible scenario
he hasn't done that

since '07 ...... 9 million jobster MIAs

235 million working age pop

since '07  the national employment ratio  has dropped from 63% to 59%

4% x 235 = ~ 9 million lop offs


Emp-pop-stalled

Friday, March 25, 2011

look at this ..do you see speculation ???

see any spec here ??



you're not supposed to

notice however the shape and timing
don't explain the two different amplitudes  here made to look similar by use of old trick
two differently calibrated scales the commodity prices moved much more %/%

falling back on elasticity still needs a price amping response mechanism to translate eh ??


but how about this....???



spec drivers live !!!!
just fooling and pretending..  under all those briary motion lines
the vertical QE commencing line here persuades ...not ...maybe


but consider this:

 crude oil prices are being "moved  " by the middle east tussles

if so ...how ???

if there is a complex pricing  mechanism at work here
that can translate changes in expectations of supply/demand
into changes in prices
then the commodity markets are not just registering changes in supply/demand

why couldn't specs manipulate these complex mechanisms ???

at least in a conducive  expectational environment

Thursday, March 24, 2011

slow up in start up- WSJ

.

The Census Bureau on Wednesday said that 403,765 new firms were started in the 12 months ended March 2009, down 17.3% from a year earlier and the fewest on records that begin in 1977.


. Firms less than a year old employed 2.3 million people in March 2009 whereas as a year earlier start-ups employed 3 million people.

.
number one reason  fewer companies got started in the most recent recession ....
 the availability of financing dried up.

and will it continue to fall ???

DESCRIPTION
 
 
from below 60% in the great society  to  the clinton miracle apex plateau of 67%
 
now down for a decade ..and  only down  ahead ???

the big picture flogged for trots

but to the main point

i think looking only here at the outcomes of policy on say the safety net occupants or our battered ever more post industrial mcshit job wage class
in the final analysis fails to capture the main driving motives of "organizations "that play their great game on a global stage
global free range profiteering today requires a stagnation...requires it ..the other options reduce global profits
in this key sense i doubt the target is local american job class opporession...we are just part of the collateral damage


----
if u start with a simple premise:

hi fi TNCs run the Fed and can have their way when necessary with the budget

but these banks are global
like so many isles of laputa they fly over the planets market systems making things happen for the great MNCs

they think globally and use uncle hegemonic pretty much as they please come a crunch
they clearly didn't want a run away contraction but they didn't want a full and fast recovery either
hence the half hearted fiscal measures

these chaps can repeal elements of the new deal but they can't repeal the laws of trade and finance

the US's chronic import gap has reached nasty levels unsustainable levels
we could devalue but like britain it would be against the euro zone and not against the emerging asian "partners"
ie
not effective
we won't devalue against the asians because that is where the big and growing profits come from

the forex tilt is a key part of the cross border arbitrage
the trade gap it creates however needs to be manzaged
and if you can't devalue or "protect"
you have to slow absorption by slowing domestic income
read romney robinson its that old hat

i submit the recent credit crisis was not wasted by the MNCs and their bankers
that crsis became the perfect pretext for a programatic stag policy

btw
if you look at the US economy as if its a closed system
even if run by trans nat corporations
all this global reality becomes an annex to domestic considerations
ie
turns the tail into the dog and the dog into the tail

trade gap story.... buffet's answer

.
"Buffett's plan proposes creating a market for transferable import certificates, (ICs) that would represent the right to import a certain dollar amount of goods into the United States. These transferable ICs would be issued to US exporters in an amount equal to the dollar amount of the goods they export and they could only be utilized once. They could be sold or traded to importers, who must purchase them in order to legally import goods into the USA. The price of ICs are set by (free-market) forces, and are therefore dependent on the balance between entrepreneurs' willingness to pay the ICs market price for importing goods into the USA and the global volume of goods exported from the USA, (i.e. supply and demand).
Proceeds from the sale of ICs would encourage exporters (who would gain that extra money in addition to the proceeds of their exports) and discourage importers (who would need to pay the additional cost to acquire ICs as well as the cost to acquire the goods they are importing). This system would essentially create a broad-based tariff on imports to the United States, and subsidy for exports – compare cap and trade, which creates a similar market in pollution"