its a great magic trick of econ con to conflate these two
a cardinal utlity ie a phlogiston with the humble market based cash income of a household
the medium of exchange has certain very useful characteristics
that even a well behaved utlity function cardinal or ordinal lacks
money value = utility value
much mischief starts with this only semi concious act
that the firm which is motivated by net income max
is somehow analogous to a household that is utliity maximizing
takes a certain rationalized stylized "realism " and makes it dissapear
the for proft firm mediating exchange gets vanished
in particular if the market system can zero out profits at equilibrium
even if equilibrium is only at the end of a path of accumulation
firms are reduced to the socially minimzed cost of transactions
the transactions that are producing by exchange pareto improving
maybe even socially maximized prior constrained aggregate utlity
now if in the market place one can only bring ones laboring capacity
skilled or not
then pareto improvement occurs at any hiring above some dreadful minimum
Saturday, April 9, 2011
Friday, April 8, 2011
what is socialism ?
Socialism in it's many morphs and various different class based conceptions
fleshes out rather compactly
iobviously quite conciously
socialism is an attempt by some class or other
to use the state to complete or to thwart
the necessary remaining world historical tasks of The bourgeois stage of class cloven social evolution
tasks that lead one way or another toward class cloven society's own sublation ... class-less society
Ie
it is a means by implementaion of legal force
to progress socially ie by other means then pure volitional private property based capitalism
In fact despite this intention
it is capitalism in other guises
capitalism pretending to be not itself
or not seeing itself for what it is or will become
capitalism
pretending or tricking itself in some cases
into thinking its being anti capitalism
...begging the big question...
this goes for any form of socialism other then the prole dictatorship form of socialism
which by exception as agent of the wage class might embody ...might ..
world historical measures that accelerate the trip time to communism
sum up
in the last analysis most socialism is simply or complexly capitalism by other means
means that in time come back around on themselves and become eventually
once again really the same means
such is clio's rubber railed road system
elastic but only finitely so
fleshes out rather compactly
iobviously quite conciously
socialism is an attempt by some class or other
to use the state to complete or to thwart
the necessary remaining world historical tasks of The bourgeois stage of class cloven social evolution
tasks that lead one way or another toward class cloven society's own sublation ... class-less society
Ie
it is a means by implementaion of legal force
to progress socially ie by other means then pure volitional private property based capitalism
In fact despite this intention
it is capitalism in other guises
capitalism pretending to be not itself
or not seeing itself for what it is or will become
capitalism
pretending or tricking itself in some cases
into thinking its being anti capitalism
...begging the big question...
this goes for any form of socialism other then the prole dictatorship form of socialism
which by exception as agent of the wage class might embody ...might ..
world historical measures that accelerate the trip time to communism
sum up
in the last analysis most socialism is simply or complexly capitalism by other means
means that in time come back around on themselves and become eventually
once again really the same means
such is clio's rubber railed road system
elastic but only finitely so
lesson
use of analogy here never got to the clear one to one map
between the two formal models elements
that is until the analogy fell apart
because a market system is not analogous to a classical thermo dynamic ideal gas system
its more like granular systems that are indeed path dependent hysterisus ridden etc etc
the intent is clear the researchers wanted certain propertties found in the classical gas to hold in a real free market system
because it made that free market system
Bof APS
between the two formal models elements
that is until the analogy fell apart
because a market system is not analogous to a classical thermo dynamic ideal gas system
its more like granular systems that are indeed path dependent hysterisus ridden etc etc
the intent is clear the researchers wanted certain propertties found in the classical gas to hold in a real free market system
because it made that free market system
Bof APS
the final dope out
"Though some aspects
of the utility/potential correspondence
can be salvaged ...."
"the lack of a natural cardinalization for general utilities
reflects the deeper fact that welfare functions simply do
not exist for general path-dependent economies."and real economiies ARE path dependent
more flaw
"gradients would equal prices
a global cardinalized welfare function
ie
the sum of all agent utilities in the economy is arrived at by adding up comensurate pools of utiles
consumed or stored by the constituent maximizing units
for all the equilibria of arbitrarily composed economies.
Such a condition is equivalent to requiring that equilibria
be maxima of " a global cardinalized welfare function
ie
the sum of all agent utilities in the economy is arrived at by adding up comensurate pools of utiles
consumed or stored by the constituent maximizing units
walrasian deadly blunder
"The fatal flaw in the Walrasian correspondence was
the assumption that cardinal forms for utilities could be
constructed"and
:"a universal addition rule for unit utilities" existed
just not so eh
at least not beyond crazy imaginary
substance abuse
utility cardinalize able utility
amounts to postulating a unicorn
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)