Friday, April 8, 2011

walras's conflation and bad analogy

walras  according to dunc :

d foley sez wrong !!!

   his thermo-con paper:
"A mechanical analogue in
economics would require not only forces, but dynamical
equivalents to inertia."



a mechanical system at rest ie with all forces initially in balance absent a shock willl stay in balance
ie  in equilibrium ie at  rest
and will stay at rest a mechanical system in motion will stay in motion

you gotta go thermal if you want an analogy to utility based exchange systems
fisher found that out thanks to mentor gibbs :


"thermodynamics, and not mechanics, is the correct physical theory
 to explain how disequilibrium systems can converge to equilibrium
and remain there."

 the original thermo con trickster  mr W
 was actually  a  simple newtonian mechanist
without a dynamic theory to get him to equilibrium
and on top of that  operating with a nasty conflation of his the unit level  the trader
and the aggregate level the market system and its total  utility state

come now statistical mechanics

but another errorfisher thinks his agents are analogous to  innocent stocastic objects
particles insideless  balls  in stochastic  motion
AND
Tto the deterministic state arrived at by these particles in mutual and interacting motion
walras/fishers  unit was an optimizing utiliton a simple  maximizer of a substance
it stores or eats
  loose in a  free for all  vol-trade  market opportunity full of other  such concious maximizer units
ready to be  trading for utils  with each other


"The potential minimized at physical equilibria is not the energy,
 as was believed in Walras’s time, but a quantity called free energy
which also receives contributions from the entropy"

"Fisher was ...drawing analogies of the economic agent to both stochastic
and deterministic physical objects at the same time"

"utility .. a measurable
quantity analogous to potential energy in mechanics"

Thursday, April 7, 2011

foley on path dependent market motion

dunc's a careful guy and a wonderland type too
this paper worries the thermo-util axis pretty hard
but he [produces the essential result
there's nothing remotely like a  one product one price rule in  actual  market driving
   and there's no way to form a unique and robust social welfare function
   in anything remotely like a realistic exchange system

this adds fill to the skeptical blitz or relative blitz that has over run the samuelson paradigm

yes paul's best work and his heart  remained with keynes and macro management
but did he press hard enough in the 70's and 80's ???

at any rate his foundations that choild prodigy magnum o
  has long since  drifted  off the continent of the dismal science
   like a calved ice berg
and as for fellow in law kenny straight arrow
he's the  old toothless eskimo  floating away on that   calf 

what does it profit you to be a socialist and never get past fixed point proofs
and the red queens deck of cards

going down with the  ss rigorous proof   ??

err melting away toward  the  equator  ??

i wonder at 90 is he  too out of it to notice
his waste ???

not that the younger of the older generations  has much to crow about

take my main man
 cousin it
joe   lamb chop  stiglitz
   progressive poli econ  happy sad sack

why the guy's  stared into the teeth  of so many  genteel neck tied audiences
and said basically the same damn thing to em  so many times
he's become like that  cement pancho they used to have at  taco bell drive thru

" welcome too dah bell  ladieeese and yentelmennnss todays espechals are ... so jew want to order  now ??
   den yust speeek into my mouwwwth "

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

could anything be much more regressive then health care premiums ??

the advance of political economy after class antagonism is patent

famously marx drew a conceptual as well as  empirical line
between  the pro active  progressive science stage of bourgois political economics
and the  reactionary regressive purely  ideologically motivated stage of the same class project
called bourgeois political economics

the  empiracal line
 br and ar
 before and after ricardo
the conceptual line
 the point where the two great and final classes of cloven society
 self conciously face off
 in open struggle  perhaps france in the summer of 1848
perhaps the  late 1820's in jolly old england

example of the two combined
the ricardian worker poli econs of the 1820-30's

but we've had a lot more bourgeois political economics since then

well first there's the bi forcation
into
   pure ideological three card montee  scam  --bastiat personfies this --
and the reconcile the unreconcliable  school ---js mill --
both of these tendencies over lap with km and the near end of his own investigations
presumeably proletarian political economy or is that recipes for cook shops of the future and thus prole class activity is limited to critiques and agit prop

but since capital  1867
 we have the deepening of the original  discoveries  of the classical bourgeois school of poli econ
 the formalizations that at least  in micro economics are considered the ruling  neo classical  paradigm
these innovations that slightly over lap with km at the far end  do not represent an advance over the classicals  merely a  deepening of the results


a process that now after another hundred years of fresh starts and  impass stops
ie points where old knots lare untied and yet lead  on to new knots
 in the plenum of strings within strings
that goes both toward a bigger string  higher more general string structure  and a smaller more specific and fine  string  structure
--note this mixed string metaphor ---
since jevons we had one big even  the great depression and one big guy keynes

the big event of my life time is of course a lot of little events between say 1970 and 1985
that put  the final and complete end to  the neo classical  micro paradigm
nearly exactly one hundred years after its inaugural triumphs

but it leaves guys like stiglitz  akerloff the makers of this destructive set of discoveries
 in a position much like js mill i think trying to reconcil the unreconcilable
where his generations bastiats lucas barro simply panglos on
its as fun to be the bastiat in this comedia del arte as its grim to be the js mill
obviously eaxctly opposing temporaments are best suited to each project
hence the slap happy glow of cousin joe
and the hemroidal wince of   doc lucas

foley on the folly of thermo dynamic market models

http://homepage.newschool.edu/~foleyd/econthermo.pdf

Tuesday, April 5, 2011

my bond dream

Moody's Seasoned Baa Corporate Bond Yield (BAA)















Graph: Moody's Seasoned Baa Corporate Bond Yield

by sammo request

http://www.thenation.com/article/159288/beyond-austerity



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chartalism
chartalism it used to be called
this guy is one of the so called new chartalists
or modern monetary theorists

consequently he hasn't a worry about peak debt
a sovereign state with debt payable entirely  in its own costlessly augmentable  un gold tied currency
can never go bankrupt if it don't want to
this means he hasn't idiotic long run burdens of short term gaping deficits to drag down his mind
as it does even the best non party line non neo liberal/neo classical poli econs ie the new post samuelson eclectics  like joe stiglitz
chumps that  still retain unexamined attachments to prudent fiscal finance for uncle
http://www.vanityfair.com/society/features/2011/05/top-one-percent-201105

mostly out of inflation fear of course

but he hasn't much else on  his mind either on that front
he's a one trick pony
ie
"The greatest lie—endlessly repeated by neoliberal economists and uncritically echoed by the mainstream media—is the claim that if governments cut their spending, the private sector will “crowd in” to fill the gap. British Prime Minister David Cameron’s austerity campaign and President Obama’s foreshadowed budget cuts are built around these lies."

true enough but ...
oh ya there's this line you've seen  else

"In the past, real wages grew in line with productivity, ensuring that firms could realize their expected profits via sales. With real wages lagging well behind productivity growth, a new way had to be found to keep workers consuming. The trick was found in the rise of “financial engineering,” which pushed ever increasing debt onto the household sector"

that begs the question why not use uncle's transfer system as is done now ??

behind this is a notion of greed pushing ever higher the rate of exploitation
as if that itself is a cyclical animal spirit
some how subdued by the great depression the world at war and the subsequent  pax americana
hmmm
i think it had more to do with changes in the global structure of capitalism
but that's for another day


i'll add
in the ike ewra rads claimed the chronic shortage of investment against nominal "acc\umulation"
 was relieved by kold war military budgets
that were nice  employment builders and effective demand maintainers

but no more that cry not after say 1975

btw
this  type of  magic bullet crusader  usually fails to notice open systems like national economies
are operating in a web of trading nations and even if their currency is still taken in exchange for products
their foreign exchange rate and their inevitable  trade gap  creates another set of macro problems
often called de industrialization

 solving domestic under employment by simply stimulating demand thru massive deficit financing
 can often make this problem far worse

in fact you notice he does have inflation and possibly exchange rates in the back of his head
as he  pops in that pinko favorite

"I would introduce an open-ended public employment program—a Job Guarantee—that offers a job at a living (minimum) wage to anyone who wants to work but cannot find employment. These jobs would “hire off the bottom,” in the sense that minimum wages are not in competition with the market-sector wage structure. By not competing with the private market, the Job Guarantee would avoid the inflationary tendencies of old-fashioned Keynesianism, which attempted to maintain full capacity utilization by “hiring off the top” (making purchases at market prices and competing for resources with all other demand elements). Job Guarantee workers would enjoy stable incomes, and their increased spending would boost confidence throughout the economy and underpin a private-spending recovery. There is no reason the government could not afford this program. The labor is available for work, and the government can easily supply the jobs. There were no questions asked when the government, in the early days of the crisis, instantly provided billions for the banks. Let me repeat: the government has no financial constraint on its spending and should immediately allocate funds to a massive job-creation program."

yup ...the uncle job gulag

despite not needing it according to pure MMT
err in a closed system mate
but open -ness
it comes from a back door limit on market driven employment created here not by import explosion
 but by high job demand by firms leading to a wage price spiral ala the infamous  70's
birth place of the mass adherence to the nairu line taboo
which is buried in this bit of fandango

the gulag is kool because

" minimum wages are not in competition with the market-sector wage structure"
oddly he fails to notice making that gulag wage a living wage would indeed lift all market earned wages right ??

" By not competing with the private market," dubious point
" the Job Guarantee would avoid the inflationary tendencies of old-fashioned Keynesianism"

here it comes
" which attempted to maintain full capacity utilization by “hiring off the top” (making purchases at market prices and competing for resources with all other demand elements)."
this  conflates demand pull inflation something impossible  with the type of capacity slack thst would trigger macro policy in the first place
with wage push inflation which happens because of corporate price cost pass thru power
he is buying into the nairu gig
without admiting it if he even clearly understands it
nairu woulsd keep the market the rate of unemployment just high enough to prevent an acceration of wage rates
now as a good rad matey
billy boy here wants to soak up  the reserve army so he offers them a iron floor wage rate job
that he flat out guarantees won't set of a wage explosion
cause he's drawing form the bottom not the top

instead of injecting enough  purchasing power into the system thru the transfer system ala 12 cylinder macro ala wild bill vickrey
letting tight markets pull wages where they may thhis plan has uncle's contrived  jobster gulag soak up the surplus labor pool
wpa a go go
and all i repeat without triggering a wage boom

how ??
its possible but only by  making sure the jobster gulag is no place any one wants to be
both wage rate wise and i suspect  conditions wise

obviously the diect necessity here
is to design and imlement a mechanism with the ability to regulate inflation set the price levl quarter by quarter
as a key and essential  part of the full  advanced solution that this guy tries to run from
ie
enter the mark up market along with the trade balancing dollar exchange rate

neither semms to be arrows in his quiver

 solve  the fear of run away inflation and de industrialization
 that  lurk like ghouls  in the hearts of white hats like joe stgilitz and paul krugman
and is why they never get to bill vickrey land