Thursday, July 12, 2012

PK repeats his morbid apothegm "Spain needs to increase exports to make up for the jobs lost when its housing bubble burst"

"Spain  faces years of a highly depressed economy
 until costs have fallen enough relative to the rest of Europe
 to achieve the needed gain in competitiveness"
pk



here's an equivalent "truth"

     to lower unemployment we need more jobs at corporations

too replace domestic demand for domestic outputs

you can either

I ) fund other domestic demand for the same outputs

or

II) find foreign demand of an equivalent size for those same domestic outputs

PK is saying Spain can't follow route I

why ?

let assume away the lack of  any ability to self finance

the ECB is no FED for Spain
still
 the import surge that would be a byproduct
 of  getting there ie back to full ouput domestically
 by means of increased domestic effective demand
ie thru a hyped up transfer payment plan
  would wildly increase the balance of payments deficit
that undergirds the banking crisis
so we assume away that problem
 by assuming an ability to self finance
and we restore that barrier toa domestic route to  recovery
 by dropping that same fanciful assumption
and end up facing the fact
Spain is much much more a  california  then a  canada

but increase exports ?


no ability to devalue unilaterally
the euro is a joint currency

no ability to get other zone members
 to accelerate their income expansion rate
and thus  as part of that expansion
accelerate  their imports  from ...spain

simply reducing imports by reducing domestic  income
might balance payments
but the real "task " is reducing relative costs of production
which in the end means reduce  relative wages

if nominal wages resist downward pressure
 
ie the   shrinking "corporate wage fund "
 simply sheds job hours not lowers wage rates
as aggregate effective nominal domestic demand shrinks

during this induced stagnation and ultra slow contraction
dynamic adjustments continue but they are ultra slow grinding adjustments
 like defaults...defaults held in suspension by banks living on
what in one direction..further grinding are probably
  too often illusory assets

at any rate look here

Spain is increasing taxes while reducing spending
precisely to reduce imports and increase downward pressure on domestic wages


 
see Spain today at point or better  range A
 where unemployment is high enough to stop aggregate nominal wage rate increases
 
to get an export kick as well as further import reduction
however Spain today needs
to move to unemployment range B where wage rates are actually falling
 
why ?
 
so the BOP gap closes fast enough to avoid a finacial crisis
ie a point where Spain can't support its total external debt load public and private
 
a better notion of wage change here might be
 
   the ratio of German wage  rates to Spanish wage  rates
 
but that highlites an alternative zonal solution
 
a wage boom in Germany !
combined with a euro deval against its eastern  EU partners
 and  EZ tradering partners  even further east and south east