Wednesday, July 18, 2012

williamson's war dance over hicks antique model

" Does the IS-LM model tell us what a financial crisis is"
no but  we know one when we're in one

 "Does the IS-LM model tell us what the policy response to such an event should be?"

 yes absolutely  and that is precisely the value of the model

it sufices to guide fiscal and monetary policy in a serious down turn


"Does it tell us what quantitative easing does?"
no
but
follow the Rx  that jumps out at you
from  hick's model and there is no need for QE

this QE gig
    is a product of our ridiculous
       " thru the fed only" contemporary
                        macronautics
in fact it's  the product of   40 plus years of trashing  fiscal activism
yup ever  since the rise of uncle milty in the late 60's

" Does it tell us the extent of inefficiency in the US economy that monetary or fiscal policy might correct?"

no

however
obviously
in a contraction like the present one   in the wake of  the '08 financial crisis
ending the huge idled elements of  the existing production system
is the order of the day
this is not about  allocation
  its about  mobilization

" Does it help us understand sovereign debt problems?"

no but domar pretty much put that to rest in the mid 40's
for anyone not afraid of
     accelerating the product price level climb
                      and pinng the nominal interest rate

 Does it help us understand how to regulate the financial system?

no and like all the other no's above
                                         just why should it ??